To Trust an Incubus

Editorial Worth it

To Trust an Incubus is a fully voiced M/M visual novel with strong artistic and audio production that delivers exactly what its premise promises: four alien incubi, abundant sex scenes, and a sci-fi setup played with earnest humor. The community consensus is largely positive—players praise the character design, voice acting (especially standout performances), world-building foundation, and the sheer volume of content (400 CGs, 35 endings). However, significant creative flaws undercut the experience: the writing is frequently called clunky, amateurish, and repetitive across routes, with plot tension resolved too quickly and scenes that feel rushed. The game prioritizes quantity (sex and endings) over narrative depth; most routes retell the same exposition from different perspectives, reducing replay incentive. An asexual character is included but mishandled—reviewers felt the writers lacked genuine understanding of asexuality, reducing his arc to manufactured drama. Players seeking story-driven romance with slow burn and emotional build-up will be disappointed; those primarily after hot art, horny humor, and bara aesthetics will find substantial entertainment. Opinion is genuinely divided: some rank it among Y Press's best work; others call the writing garbage and feel the $20 price point unjustified for 2–3 hours of unique content per route.