Editorial Meh
The Collar is a repackaged version of a 2014 text-based CYOA game, originally authored by JoeForest, that has resurfaced here with AI-generated images added by what the community broadly believes to be an unauthorised third party — the actual JoeForest has commented to confirm he did not make or sanction this release. The underlying story is a modest mind-control/submission fantasy from a decade ago: serviceable for its niche, though critics note the writing shows its age and ambition, with a few branching paths and a clear D/s premise. As a creative work it lands as a competent early effort that some in its target audience will enjoy for what it is. The real consensus issue is the AI art grafted onto the original text: reviewers document image–scene mismatches, absent collar imagery despite the collar being the title object and core mechanic, cloned characters, continuity errors, and clothing choices that ignore the player's selections. The images add little and frequently distract from the text. The game runs fine as a Twine piece, but the community overwhelmingly views the AI treatment as careless and unnecessary, and many recommend either seeking out the 2014 HTML-only original or exploring the author's later, higher-quality work instead.
Description
Screenshots