Editorial Has potential
Idle Guild is an early-stage idle game with a solid core loop and appealing artwork that shows real promise. Players appreciate the relaxed gameplay concept and character art, and several have already committed to following development. However, the build has significant technical issues: the third guild quest crashes with a hard error for multiple players, progression becomes exponentially gated (making idle play effectively impossible at later stages), and date scenes beyond the first are inaccessible. The stat system is also confusing, and audio is sparse. Community consensus is cautiously optimistic about the direction, but the current version needs stabilization and balance adjustments before it feels complete.
Description
Screenshots